PDA

View Full Version : Lest We Forget


Yahya
01-12-2005, 06:47 AM
On 15th July 1410 AD, a combined force of Polish, Lithuanians and Russians met the German Knights of the Teutonic Order in the First Battle of Tannenberg. The German Knights fought heroically but were defeated. They lost all their banners (each banner signifying a unit). The Teutonic Knights blamed the Russians for their defeat. The priest Anton Grabener of Lubeck wrote a report shortly after the battle to various Crown heads of Europe claiming that there were 100,000 heathen Tatars, which was why the Teutonic Knights were defeated. The Germans never forgot the defeat and the valour of their Knights in that battle. Five hundred years later, in August 1914, at the Second Battle of Tannenberg, the German Army routed the Russians taking over 90,000 prisoners.
On 16th December 1971, Commander Eastern Command Lieutenant General Amir Abdullah Khan Niazi surrendered to the Indian Army. That day we not only lost more than half of our country but also our pride. Also lost in the recriminations that followed were the stories of courage and sacrifice of our officers and men in former East Pakistan. Stories of courage displayed not only in battlefield, but also moral courage.
On 4th March 1971, Lieutenant General Sahibzada Yakub Ali Khan Commander Eastern Command resigned when he failed to convince President Yahya Khan to visit Dacca in order to negotiate a political solution with Awami League. Fifteen days later the courageous commander of the Pakistan Air Force in East Pakistan, Air Commodore Zafar Masud (popularly known as ‘Mitty’) stood up during a briefing to President Yahya Khan and pleaded for a political solution. Air Commodore Masud, a 1965 War hero, under whose leadership the outnumbered but valiant pilots from the Pakistan Air Force Base Sargodha outfought the Indians in the air, had placed his career on line. A few days later he was relieved of his duties. Both Lieutenant General Yakub and Air Commodore Masud displayed moral courage at a time when this commodity was as rare as it is now.
Notwithstanding the outcome of the events of 1971 in former East Pakistan, the war is full of accounts of bravery of our men in that theatre. The defence of Hili by 4 Frontier Force and the heroism of Major Akram (Shaheed), Nishan-e-Haider are stories which make up legends. At Kamalpur, Captain Ahsan Malik and his men surrounded from all sides had beaten back repeated Indian assaults since 14th November. On 3rd December he was asked by the Indian commander to surrender. Ahsan’s men were out of ammunition and supplies. He refused to surrender although he had nothing to back it up with. That night the enemy overran the post. At Jamalpur, Lieutenant Colonel Sultan Ahmad, Commanding Officer 31 Baluch, was in a similar situation. Surrounded, his line of communication cut off, he fought on. On 10th December, Brigadier Hardyal Singh Kler Commander of 95th Indian Brigade (that had surrounded the Jamalpur garrison) sent a note asking Colonel Sultan to surrender. Sultan returned the note with a bullet enclosed in it and asked the Indian commander to ‘give up the pen and take up the sten gun’. These and many other accounts of heroism epitomise the stock to which the fighting men of our nation belong.
The outcome of Kargil conflict may not have been in Pakistan’s favour, but it is replete with accounts of gallantry of our soldiers – some of which have been acknowledged by the Indians as well. Burying these tales of courage and sacrifice in the ashes of defeat will be an injustice to those who have shed their blood for the nation and also deprive our future generations of heroes and role models to emulate.
We do not have to wait five hundred years to avenge our defeat in former East Pakistan. We also do not necessarily have to wage a military campaign to do so. If we can gain from the lessons of defeat, take inspiration from our heroes (in all fields) and start emulating them, we would emerge as a strong and a proud nation.
Let us not forget our heroes. Nations who do that never get to be anywhere. As a nation that is surrounded by darkness where role models are concerned we need to look at our success stories, no matter how small, and tell them to our youth. Our success stories will act like rays of light in the darkness. If we can come up with enough of these, perhaps, there will be light.


Yahya Jamil-ul-Haq

iqbal's
01-12-2005, 08:11 AM
Well said.There is too much pessimissm and cynicism put out by the so called itellectuals which just shoes the dark side all the time.It is time to project the positive side too.Keep a balance.

Usman Shabbir
01-12-2005, 10:57 AM
I have read about both Captain Ahsan Malik and Lt Col Sultan in Salik’s ‘Witness to Surrender’. Lt Col Sultan was killed later in an operation and Captain Ahsan was taken POW. Does anyone know what happened to Captain Ahsan after the war? When did he retire and at what rank?

Yahya
01-12-2005, 11:16 AM
Usman sahib,
you are probably confusing identities. Lt Col Sultan survived and was awarded the Sitara-i-Jurat for the second time. He had earned his first in 1965. He became a Brigadier and I had the honour of serving under his command in Balochistan in 1970's. He retired in 1978. He died in May 2000. His book 'The Stolen Victory' is a something worth reading. Captain Ahsan Malik was serving in the Army till 80's. But I lost track of him thereafter.

Shoaib
01-12-2005, 12:44 PM
Assalamu aleikum,

Yahya, could you provide more info on the book and where to get hold of it? WOuld be nice if you could post that in this thread:

http://www.pakdef.info/forum/showthread.php?t=4951&highlight=magazines

Thanks in advance!

W'salam

Yahya
01-12-2005, 12:54 PM
Shoaib,
the book is probably out of print. I have my copy but I am actually involved in preparing a series of Telefilms based on events as narrated in the book and therefore cannot spare it. ISPR has a copy and maybe some friends of the late Brigadier would have a copy.
I do intend having it reprinted (with permission of the family of Brigadier Sultan ofcourse) but after the production of telefilms.

Usman Shabbir
01-13-2005, 06:01 AM
Usman sahib,
you are probably confusing identities. Lt Col Sultan survived and was awarded the Sitara-i-Jurat for the second time. He had earned his first in 1965. He became a Brigadier and I had the honour of serving under his command in Balochistan in 1970's. He retired in 1978. He died in May 2000. His book 'The Stolen Victory' is a something worth reading. Captain Ahsan Malik was serving in the Army till 80's. But I lost track of him thereafter.

Yes, thanks for the correction. I confused the Col Sultan of 31 Baluch with that of 32 Baluch (also named Sultan). Who published the book 'The Stolen Victory' and when did it came out?

Yahya
01-13-2005, 09:20 AM
The book was published in 1996 by Maktaba-Tul-Mukhtar, 4 Gulistan Colony, Rawalpindi Cantt. Very few copies were printed as the late Brigadier did not have the necessary funds and the publisher probably was reluctant to print more than 500 copies. Although the quality of printing is bad, but the book is an absorbing reading. In fact the first telefilm that I have produced is based on a very powerful episode from the book . The book is in two parts. First part deals with the operations of 8 Baloch in 1965 and also the operations of then Captain Sultan's company as part of Gibraltor Force. The second part deals with the operations of 31 Baloch in former East Pakistan. Maybe you can get a copy from the publisher.
At one stage the Army Book Club had shown interest in it. I do not know what became of it.

SyedA
01-13-2005, 09:33 AM
Yahya

if you mail the book to me or Usman, we can scan the whole book at put it on the website.

Yahya
01-13-2005, 10:21 AM
Syed sahib,
where are you located.

SyedA
01-13-2005, 10:28 AM
yahya Bhai

Please check your private message.